cyberspacial musings
bits about the real and virtual worlds

19 Apr

Pen-Based Input

Anoto has created a device that allows text to be entered into a computer using a special pen. While this appears to have been done before in various forms (Mimeo and Crosspad, for example), the Anoto pen takes a slightly different approach. Instead of just recording the stokes that the pen takes, Anoto uses a special paper with a pattern of dots on it. This allows the system to know exactly where the pen is and to customize the input accordingly. So, for example, if checking the OK box on the page means that the content can be e-mailed, the system would be able to tell what the marking was and where it was on the page. The pen uses Bluetooth technology to transmit the information that the pen collects into similarly enabled devices — cell phones, PDAs, etc. The full details are on their “functionality” web site.

I have to say that this is one of the most compelling implementations of this technology that I’ve seen, but I remain skeptical about it’s usefulness. IBM produced a device called the Thinkpad TransNote, which was delivered with a writing tablet that captured pen strokes into an attached notebook computer (Business 2.0 — “Great Looking Product” sidebar When Good Designs Go Bad. The CrossPad also died — a system of paper and RF pen that transmitted text into a computer. Mimeo is a whiteboard system that stores the contents in a computer, but the form factor and clunky way of connecting to the computer has made that device all but useless.

So I think that Anoto is a longshot. The use of Bluetooth, a wireless technology for communicating over 10 meter distances, is a double-edged sword. On the plus side, wirelessly transmitting data from the pen into the computer or cell phone improves the odds of use, especially since the pen doesn’t look too large (at least from the pictures on their web site). But Bluetooth seems to me to be fading rapidly — 802.11/Wi-Fi has been all the rage and companies are applying it to all sorts of problems — including those problems that Bluetooth was intended to solve. Don’t misunderstand me on this — Wi-Fi was not designed to be the low power cable replacement technology like Bluetooth. It just turns out that the Wi-Fi folks are rapidly developing technology that will essentially replace Bluetooth, thus hindering Bluetooth’s adoption. So I don’t anticipate that a large number of devices will work with Anoto’s pen technology.

Frankly, I’m skeptical about the special paper too. Maybe certain environments, for example hospitals, where paper is normal will be a good target market for Anoto. But many business are rapidly moving to PDA and tablet technology that will likely overtake the market for pen and paper based solutions. I’d therefore expect Anoto get great hype because of its cool technology, but ultimately it will become a niche solution.

Leave a Reply

cyberspacial musings is is proudly powered by Wordpress and the Magellan Theme

Contact me at <jeff@jeffreykay.com> if you'd like to comment on this site.


All content on this site copyright © 2002-2009 by Jeffrey Kay. All Rights Reserved. Other trademarks are the properties of their respective owners. All views and opinions contained in the columns, interviews, or other articles on this site are solely the opinion of the writer.